107 North Michigan Avenue, Big Rapids, Michigan 49307
231-796-5881 9AM - 5PM MON - FRI

Insurance Companies

Schuberg Agency represents these insurance companies. With several of the largest and most respected companies, we’re confident we can find the best coverage & rates for you.

American Modern Insurance Group
Payment Information

800-543-2644
7000 Midland Blvd
Amelia, OH 45102-2607
amig.com

Claims Information

800-375-2075
amig.com

Auto Owners Insurance
Payment Information

800-346-0346
P.O. Box 30660
Lansing, MI 48917
customercenter.auto-owners.com

Claims Information

800-346-0346
autoowners.com

Foremost Insurance
Payment Information

800-532-4221
P.O. Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
foremost.com

Claims Information

800-527-3907
foremost.com

Frankenmuth
Payment Information

844.488.9777
1 Mutual Avenue
Frankenmuth, MI 48787
fmins.com/customers/make-payment/

Claims Information

1-800-234-4433
fmins.com/phs/fileAClaim.aspx

Hanover Insurance Group
Payment Information

800-573-1187
PO Box 580045
Charlotte, NC 28258-0045
hanover.com/billing.html

Claims Information

800-628-0250
hanover.com/claims.html

Progressive
Payment Information

800-876-5581
P.O. Box 4640
Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601
progressiveagent.com

Claims Information

800-274-4499
progressiveagent.com

Selective Insurance Company of America
Payment Information

888-974-7400
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
selective.com/info-center/pay-my-bill

Claims Information

866-455-9969
selective.com/info-center/claim-center